Your Pie Pizza Menu
Your Pie Pizza menu gallery
Choose your favorite dish
Pizza
Ischia Margherita, Nat's Chicken Pesto Pizza, Lineage Supreme, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Great White Pizza, Chicken BBQ Bacon Ranch Pizza, and Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza!
Craft Series Pizza available all year (marinara, mozzarella, mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives, pepperoni, & Italian sausage)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (BBQ sauce, mozzarella, red onions, cilantro, chicken, bacon, & ranch)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (extra virgin olive oil, ricotta, mozzarella, feta, & garlic)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (basil pesto, mozzarella, feta, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, and chicken)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet peppadew peppers, house-pickled jalapeños, basil, feta, & hot honey)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (buffalo sauce, mozzarella, red onions, jalapenos, & chicken, served with ranch or blue cheese dressing)
Craft Series Pizza available all year (extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, garlic)
Select your cheese and add pepperoni - our pepperoni pizza now has twice as much pepperoni!
Choose from shredded mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, feta, ricotta, parmesan, or vegan cheese (or combine multiple!)
Choose from over 60 fresh ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and homemade sauces.
Gluten-free pizza crust available upon request. Upcharges may apply.
Keto-friendly cauliflower crust available upon request. Upcharges may apply.
Choose from vegan white, wheat, or gluten-free pizza crust and include our vegan cheese, vegan protein, and various veggies!
Includes 12oz drinks & 1 scoop gelato, 7" small pizza (2 toppings for cheese) OR cheesy alfredo pasta.
Salad
Romaine, parmesan, croutons, black pepper, and caesar dressing
Spinach, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, basil, black pepper, and balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Romaine, black olives, red onion, banana peppers, feta, and greek dressing
Choose from over 60 fresh ingredients
Pasta
Penne pasta, basil pesto, sundried tomatoes, spinach, chicken, mozzarella, and feta
Penne pasta, marinara, mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, basil, garlic, and meatball
Penne pasta, extra virgin olive oil, ricotta, mozzarella, feta, and garlic.
Choose from over 60 fresh ingredients and homemade sauces
Desserts
Italian Gelato is made differently than ice cream, with milk instead of cream. Its decadence comes from the rich flavors of all-natural ingredients, not added butterfat. You would never guess it was 93% fat-free. Flavors may vary. Call ahead for in-stock flavors.
Individually wrapped brownies.
Combine a brownie with Italian gelato to make it a sundae.
Additional Items
Each Your Pie hand selects the brews offered, making the beer list at all locations unique.
Call ahead to ask about our wine selection, including summer chilled wines and reds.
Our high quality and fresh toppings include pepperoni, bacon, chicken, Italian sausage, meatballs, ham, plant-based sausage, arichoke hearts, bananas peppers, basil, black olives, broccoli, cilantro, garlic, green bell peppers, fresh jalapenos, house-made pickled jalapenos, mushrooms, oregano, pineapple, red onion, romaine, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and tomatoes.
Our salad dressing selection includes balsamic vinaigrette, caesar, greek, and ranch.
Our signature homemade sauces include marinara & basil pesto. We also serve extra virgin olive oil, buffalo sauce, BBQ sauce, ranch, and alfredo sauce.
Our cheese selection includes shredded mozarella, fresh mozarella, feta, ricotta, parmesan, ricotta, and vegan cheese.
Our pizza dough options include white bread (7" or 10" or 14"), wheat (7" or 10"), keto-friendly cauliflower crust (10"), and gluten-free crust (10").
Our cheesy breadsticks with marinara make an excellent addition to your pizza or pasta!
Coke products available for dine-in and to-go orders
All of your favorite Your Pie pizzas, pastas, and sides available for catering. Contact us today to place your catering order with a friendly staff member.
Your Pie Pizza in Lumberton, NC offers a delightful variety of menu items that cater to all tastes, from pizza lovers to those looking for lighter options or indulgent treats. Their Craft Series Pizzas offer unique, flavorful combinations, including the Lineage Supreme Pizza and BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. If you're craving something classic yet rich, the Great White Pizza and Nat's Chicken Pesto Pizza are standout choices, each with their own distinctive taste profiles.
For those looking to balance their meal with something fresh, the restaurant offers several salad options, including the crisp Caesar Salad, the refreshing Caprese Salad, and the Mediterranean-inspired Greek Salad. If you're in the mood for customization, you can always Build Your Own Salad to your exact liking, choosing from a wide variety of toppings.
Pasta enthusiasts will enjoy hearty dishes like Nat's Chicken Pasta Bake, Zia's Meatball Marinara Pasta, and the creamy Cheesy Alfredo Pasta. You can also Build Your Own Pasta by selecting your favorite ingredients, ensuring a personalized dining experience.
For dessert, Your Pie Pizza serves up a sweet selection with Gelato, Brownie, and the indulgent Brownie Sundae, which is perfect for those who want to finish their meal on a sweet note.
In addition to the main menu, the restaurant also offers a selection of Craft Beer and Wine, ideal for pairing with your pizza or pasta. Don't forget to explore the wide range of Pizza Toppings, Salad Dressings, and Homemade Sauces, which allow you to further customize your meal to suit your tastes.
Overall, Your Pie Pizza’s menu is diverse, with something for everyone-from savory pizzas and pasta to fresh salads and decadent desserts. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a full meal, this restaurant has you covered.